It’s hard to discuss my relationship with my sister without giving 21 years of backstory.
In sum, I know her better than anyone else. For better, or worse.
We’re complete opposites, both physically and emotionally. Sometime after I went to college (and, not coincidentally I’m sure, the same time we stopped sharing a bathroom), we forged a pretty tight bond. We don’t speak every day and we certainly don’t agree on everything but we’re close. There for each other. Supportive.
Which, of course, is why she can hurt me more than anyone else can.
My sister has a history of hitting below the belt. She is analytical and whip-smart and knows exactly what buttons to push and how exactly to push them in order to maximize effectiveness. If she’s angry, if she’s hurt, if she’s vulnerable, she aims for the jugular. And, while she’s certainly going to be a great litigation lawyer some day, being in her line of fire can make even the strongest man or woman cower in a corner and beg for mercy.
The fact that she’s model-gorgeous just adds to the effect.
She was in a snippy mood all this past weekend. I understood, to a degree. Emotions, coupled with the difficult task of coordinating 20 relatives in town for the event, were running high.
However, we were all having a great time at dinner on Saturday night until a few of my aunts brought up my impending engagement. They asked me when I thought it would happen and what type of ring I wanted. I answered them enthusiastically (the best way to get me to smile these days is to bring up any of the following words: “engagement,” “ring,” “wedding.”)
My sister, in front of the entire table, rolled her eyes and commented that the engagement was all I could talk about (not true! I can also speak extensively about shoes and my new favorite restaurant.)Then, in her most biting tone, she said “I mean, you’re not even engaged yet. And who knows if you will be. I mean, who knows how long you and M will last?” (Apropos of nothing, mind you, as she loves M and knows that we are a strong couple.)
Everyone was momentarily shocked before my father made a witty comment and all was soon forgotten by everyone but me. To be honest, it’s not the most horrible thing she’s ever said to me. However, it hurt right down to my core. This is my sister, this is my future maid of honor, this is someone who is supposed to be excited about me getting engaged just as I am excited beyond words for her to start the post-college chapter of her life. The fact that she was so venomous and dismissive had me fighting back tears.
She hasn’t apologized, and she won’t. She’s stubborn and prideful and is used to everyone just forgiving her and moving on so as to keep the peace in the family. As much as I am adamant about standing my ground at the moment, I know that there will come a time when I will cave and forgive, if not forget.
But right now, it’s still hurtful. My parents have assured me that it comes from a place of jealousy and that she didn’t really mean it and that she’s still young. All true, but not enough to make me shrug and say “you’re right, silly me, I shouldn’t be so upset.” At least not yet.
I hate to paint a negative picture of her because in many ways, she’s so amazing. She’s smart and witty and sophisticated and gorgeous and many other positive adjectives. She just also happens to be a bitch sometimes.
The truth is, I can’t wait until M and I do get engaged and then married and then pregnant and then and then and then…Because I hope that one day, when she and I are in our eighties and I’m still happily married to M, I will be lucid enough to remember and then turn to her and say, “what was that about M and I not lasting?”
Yowch. I don’t know what it is like to have a sister, but to have ANYONE suggest that about your relationship especially a relative is hurtful.
And, she’s 21. I mean, how different were we when we were 21. I’m sure I said a lot worse.
Wow. That’s cold. And that young? No excuse. She’s graduating college, she’s an adult, and that was a deliberately mean and hurtful thing to say.
She may have just been jealous, but it’s okay that you’re upset, because that was nasty and she is certainly old enough to be held accountable for her words. That said, I’m glad you know you’ll forgive her. Ultimately, they’re just words and they won’t change your reality.
My sister and I are the same way, except she’s seven years younger. I love her so much it actually hurts sometimes, but she can knock me down like no one else.
While I do think it probably came from jealousy and stress, I can totally understand while it did (and still does) hurt.
It will be awesome when you can turn to her and laugh at how wrong she was.
This is way about her and not about you at all. I wouldn’t ignore it, but at the same time chose your words wisely. “I felt very hurt when you….” Take ownership for how you allowed her to make you feel and let her know. You’ll come out the better person for it and I think you’ll feel much more at piece for saying something. All the people who ignore it and push it under the rug are just enabling the behavior!
that would be “PEACE”!! LOL!!
My sister got married a little less than two years ago, and recently had a baby. (My YOUNGER sister, mind you.) As much as you might like your future sib-in-law, there’s always a bit of … I don’t know if jealousy is the word but it’s similar. Marriage changes things. Suddenly there’s another PERSON in your life and your family dynamic just isn’t the same anymore. Marriage is a major life change for everyone. If you haven’t already, TALK to her about why she’s acting out.
Here’s a story. My sister and I bought our mom a digital picture frame for Mother’s Day, and after loading it up with wedding pics and pics of my (truly awesome and adorable) nephew, my mom turned to me and said, “Don’t worry, I’ll add one of you too.” Uh, thanks, Mom, how nice of you … But you know what I mean — she feels left out.
I completely understand your being hurt at when she said that hurtful thing about your relationship. I am a little sister though so I can understand her side, too. I think that she was jealous because at her graduation dinner you were getting the spotlight because of your impending engagement. If I were her I would be upset, too. It was “her” party and though you didn’t bring up the topic you were stealing some of her thunder, so to speak. I, obviously, don’t know the whole story but given the facts, I think that is the root of the problem.
That makes me glad I’m an only child. I agree with notbubbly, she was just being a pain because you were stealing her spotlight. That’s no reason to justify what she said, of course but you also got to understand it. Anyway, hope you guys work everything out. =]
I think everyone is sort of mixing up the words “envy” and “jealousy”, similar but not the same. Your sister is obviously envious of you, but I know that I have also bitten off on one of my best friends (who are basically my sisters) in the same manner when she talked endlessly about something she was excited about.
She could also have been hurt that it was her graduation weekend, a weekend where the attention is supposed to be on her.
And please do not take this in the wrong way, because I do not know you or your future fiance, but I was once engaged as well. My friends also loved my fiance, but warned me not to count my chickens with the entire situation. I replied with a response much similar to yours, the “I told you so’s” at an old age. I’m obviously not engaged anymore…
Caitlyn–you might be right, but I definitely meant jealous. Maybe she is envious that she doesn’t have the same thing in her life, but she is probably also afraid of losing her relationship with Clink now that someone else is in the picture. Don’t you think?
I’m so glad I didn’t get a little sister like I asked Santa for that one year.
Wow… I’m pretty sure we have the same sister. My sister is four years younger, weighs 95 pounds soaking wet and is drop dead gorgeous. And man, can she scathe when she’s upset about something. It usually has nothing to do with me, but I seriously SO know how you feel.
Hey Sam aka jpbriscoe@mindspring.com aka assvice giver: I remember you. I remember that you always like to leave obnoxious comments. Hey, whatever gets you off. However, I’ll be deleting them from here on out. Ciao!
Wow, clink. You and your sister are a lot alike.
Just kidding
Strangebird, that does make sense. I was just noticing that almost everyone kept saying jealous as in wanting what she had.
And now I really wanna know what Sam said to set Clink off like that.
not to excuse your sister from her obvious bad behavior, but she may have felt a little like you were stealing her thunder. a day after my boyfriend and i decided we were going to move in together my younger sister got engaged, and as you may imagine no one cared much about me and the boy moving in together.
fast forward 6 months and i am about to be engaged (sidenote: how are you not a bundle of anxiety and nerves. granted i am a complete control freak who has to know everything, but every day i am seriously on the verge of beating information on the impending engagement out of the boy.) and now my sister is very concerned about me stealing her thunder.
so chalk your sister’s comment up to the beauty of sisterly relationships. as much as we love each other there is always that underlying competitiveness, who does mom and dad love more, who has accomplished more, who is getting the most attention. no matter how much we love and support our siblings we are always going to measure ourselves against them.
Gah, that’s kind of nasty of her! It probably stems from jealousy, though. Don’t let it get to you!
I guarantee she was simply a little jealous of you and felt like it was her night. Younger sisters always have a bit of a shadow of the older sister to contend with. Whatever the reason, you are lucky to have each other. Luckier than you realize.